Subversion of Women in Indian Society: A Mask of Patriarchy Hidden in Jokes

In Indian society, patriarchy is woven deeply into the fabric of family structures, social institutions, and everyday life. Men have long used subtle and overt means to subvert women’s voices and expressions, maintaining dominance in ways that are both glaring and insidious. Feminist scholars have extensively explored the ways men subordinate women, laying bare the various strategies through which patriarchy manifests in homes, workplaces, and public spaces. Their research has illuminated how men exercise control over women, often by silencing, restricting, and infantilising them. As I delved into these academic works, I gained a nuanced understanding of the pervasive nature of gender inequality.

However, what perplexes me is how different the reality feels when I visit my village or observe casual family interactions, particularly in the media and pop culture. In spaces that are far removed from the scholarly lens, the narrative often shifts to one of supposed female dominance, particularly that of wives over their husbands. Television shows, comedy skits, and even personal conversations are replete with jokes about husbands being “emasculated” or controlled by their wives. There’s an oddly prevalent theme of wives holding superiority over their husbands, a form of playful banter that suggests women wield more power within the family dynamic than men. The reality, however, couldn’t be further from the truth.

The Disconnect Between Academia and Popular Culture

The contrast between what feminist scholars reveal and what everyday jokes portray is striking. In academic discourse, women’s oppression is well-documented and analysed. Books on subversion detail how women are silenced, subjected to patriarchal norms, and deprived of autonomy. Yet, when I step outside of academia and into the living rooms of families or watch a popular family comedy, I notice a radically different narrative—one that seems to reverse these roles. There is a near-constant joke, not about male superiority, but rather about how husbands are “henpecked,” submissive, or even afraid of their wives.

This discourse of women’s dominance, particularly of wives over husbands, exists as a form of comedic relief in Indian society. There are countless jokes about the “power” of women over their husbands, presenting wives as the real decision-makers and husbands as figures who comply with their demands. It’s easy to get confused by this duality. Are men truly acknowledging the dominance of women in some spheres, or is there something more complex at play?

A Psychological and Societal Compensatory Mechanism

After reflecting deeply on this contradiction, I came to realise that these jokes about the superiority of wives are not reflections of reality but rather a compensatory mechanism deployed by men. In private, men often subvert women in various ways, asserting dominance in the domestic sphere through control over finances, decision-making, and personal freedoms. In many cases, this subversion is subtle yet powerful—women are not allowed to express themselves freely, and their choices are shaped by the men in their lives. But, when it comes to publicly acknowledging this inequality, men cleverly deflect attention by making light-hearted jokes about their supposed submission to women.

This, I believe, is a psychological tactic. By positioning themselves as the ones being dominated in public discourse—albeit through jokes—men can maintain the illusion that all is well in the patriarchal structure. The propagation of this narrative allows them to avoid the uncomfortable truth of their own subversive behaviour. By laughing off the idea of wives dominating their husbands, men soothe their own consciences. It creates a false sense of balance—”Yes, we dominate, but women dominate us too!”—thus avoiding any real reflection on the deep-seated inequities that continue to exist.

The Role of Women in This Narrative

What’s even more intriguing is that women, too, often participate in these narratives. Many women, especially wives, seem to enjoy the public recognition that they “control” their husbands, finding some sense of empowerment in these jokes. It’s not uncommon for women to laugh along or even fuel these narratives, perhaps because, in a society where their actual power is so limited, this symbolic gesture of superiority offers some small comfort. However, this sense of control is purely superficial. It distracts from the very real ways in which women are oppressed. The supposed dominance of wives over husbands in jokes does little to change the realities of patriarchal control that operates behind closed doors.

In fact, this is precisely how patriarchy protects itself. Allowing this narrative to exist maintains the façade that power dynamics between men and women are more equal than they truly are. It allows both men and women to feel that there’s nothing wrong with the structure—after all, wives seem to be in control, right? But this “control” is illusory. The societal order remains untouched, and the underlying patriarchal mechanisms continue to operate smoothly, reinforced by the very jokes that seem to subvert them.

The Subversive Power of Jokes in Indian Society

In this way, humour becomes a tool for maintaining the status quo. By constantly repeating these jokes, society creates a shared understanding that women, particularly wives, hold some level of power over their husbands. This narrative serves as a protective veil for men, masking their subversive behaviour in the domestic sphere and allowing them to evade accountability. These jokes do not threaten the patriarchal structure; instead, they reinforce it by offering a superficial counterbalance to the very real subjugation women experience.

In conclusion, the subversion of women in Indian society is a complex and multifaceted process. Men dominate, bully, and silence women in countless ways, but they smartly turn the narrative into public by claiming a kind of victimhood masked in humour. This unique form of subversion allows both individuals and the broader societal structure to avoid confronting the ugly truths of patriarchy, enabling its continued existence under the guise of balance. Women’s subordination remains deeply ingrained despite these narratives of superficial female superiority. Understanding this duality is crucial if we are to challenge the deep-rooted patriarchal norms that persist in Indian society.